Here’s something you don’t see every day: Carlo Maria Giulini conducting the Vienna Symphony in the Emperor Waltz by Johann Strauss, Jr. The sound isn’t great, but who cares?
Here’s something you don’t see every day: Carlo Maria Giulini conducting the Vienna Symphony in the Emperor Waltz by Johann Strauss, Jr. The sound isn’t great, but who cares?
March 24, 2014
Comments RSS and TrackBack URI
This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.
As much as I admire Giulini, I’m not so sure on this performance. I’m missing the lightness and a bit of fun in it…two traits he was not known for. If I were just watching the video without sound, I might guess he was conducting Bruckner. Even though this isn’t the Vienna Phil, I can see why he never conducted the famous New Year’s concerts.
Watching an orchestral video without sound may be a curious exercise, but i think listening to it without watching is more telling. So i tried that and at first i thought that chris’s objections were exaggerated – the performance seemed quite beautiful to me, in spite of the poor quality of the recorded sound. But somewhere between 4 and 5 minutes into the piece, it became so slow and ponderous, all ritards so overdone and all forte passages so bombastic, that i had to agree – the Maestro is nowhere near his best in this kind of music.
You’re both right. But there are moments …
The sound isn’t great, but who cares?
Sorry, Tim, but that doesn’t make sense to me. It’s like going to a five-star restaurant, being told by the owner that the ingredients are selected from the food aisle of the 99 Cents store a few miles away, and my saying, “but who cares?”
What I meant is that the video is more of an opportunity to see and hear Giulini conduct a piece he is not normally associated with. You put up with the sound in such a case.
I guess I was more wary than I should have been about what you actually meant since I recall in the past hashing over the matter of an orchestral performance, its quality and appeal, and the importance of the acoustics surrounding it.